|
The role of sport in the construction of masculinities in an English independent junior school |
|
This article concerns the central role of organised sport in the construction of masculinity amongst Year 6 boys (10 to 11-year-olds) at an English independent (fee-paying) junior school. The data come from an ethnographic study of one year's duration that investigated constructions of masculinity among two classes. The formal school culture consciously promoted a range of sports/games and made them an integral part of a competitive, masculine regime, although the informal peer-group culture gave primacy to football. The leading form of masculinity embodied was the sporty boy, which was sanctioned by the school, and this gave it a powerful cultural and social authority. The body played a vital part: groups of boys were classified and divided by their physicality/athleticism, which restricted the opportunities for most boys to compete for this ideal. Although I have taken the terms 'hegemonic' 'complicit' and 'subordinated' forms of masculinity' from Connell, I found it necessary to propose another form and relation of masculinity, which I have called 'personalised'. Personalised forms were made up from the majority of boys who appeared content to pursue their own types of identity and did not aspire to, or imitate, the leading form. Only a very few of the boys who were not sporty were subordinated by the dominant regime, although this was also due to a series of other factors which are further explored.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Learning gender in primary school playgrounds: findings from the Tomboy Identities Study |
|
This paper starts from the idea that children learn and construct gendered identities within local communities of masculinity and femininity practice, including peer communities. The data presented come from an ESRC-funded study of tomboy identities, which investigated the enabling and constraining factors for girls in taking up and maintaining tomboy identities, and the relationship between these and the perpetuation of active girlhood during the later primary school years. The paper considers how gender is constructed within the physical spaces of school playgrounds. We contrast the spatialities of the two research sites—one, an inner-city school with restricted playground space; the other, an outer-London school with extensive grounds—and examine the implications of these for children's activities and associated identities. We show how the spaces of the school and the surrounding area are factors in the children's construction of their identities, and how playground space is used partly to construct and maintain gender difference by both girls and boys. In particular, we examine how children use play as a means to the construction of their masculinities and femininities, and how these are enabled and constrained by their peer communities.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Who are tomboys and how do we recognise them? |
|
This article reports on the findings of an exploratory study of tomboy identities. Based on case study data of children aged nine to eleven in two contrasting London schools, we attempt to tease out how children of this age, their teachers and parents, understand the term ‘tomboy’, how they relate it to the identities of themselves and others, the extent to which such identities can be taken up and maintained, and the relationship between these and active play in pre-pubertal girls. The study is theoretically grounded in the idea that masculinities and femininities are individually and collectively negotiated within local communities of masculinity and femininity practice, so that the identities that any individual can take up are locally governed and constructed.
It was unusual to identify unproblematically as a tomboy, though several girls described themselves as ‘a bit tomboy’. Although active play remains possible for some girls as they come to the end of primary schooling, for others their movement becomes restricted, due to a number of factors. This has longer-term implications for the range of identities available to teenage girls, and for their physical well-being.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Sporting bodies, ageing, narrative mapping and young team athletes: an analysis of possible selves |
|
Drawing on life history data generated from interviews with young athletes at an English university, this paper explores the narrative maps provided to them by older team members and the ways in which these influence perceptions of self-ageing. Three possible selves associated with mid-life emerged from the analysis for detailed focus. These are the preferred self (Almost past it), the feared self (Hanging on) and the reluctant self (Stepping aside). The implications of each of these selves for the ageing experience are considered. Finally, some suggestions are made as to how the narrative resources of young athletes might be expanded.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Friendship, physicality, and physical education: an exploration of the social and embodied dynamics |
|
...of girls' physical education experiences
Physical education represents a dynamic social space where students experience and interpret physicality in a context that accentuates peer relationships and privileges particular forms of embodiment. This article focuses on girls' understandings of physicality with respect to the organisation of physical education and more informal social networks. Research exploring the connections between the body, capital, physical activity, and femininity and work on friendship and other social relationships underpin the study. The article draws on findings from ethnographic work involving 12- and 13-year-old girls in a multi-ethnic, mixed comprehensive school in the United Kingdom. The meaning of physicality was interwoven with differences in social status, membership in friendship groups, gender ideologies, and ethnicity. Girls' interpretations of their experiences centred on their perceptions of the importance of displays of competence and the ways that practices in physical education reinforced and challenged their social networks. Girl-only physical education contexts did not emerge as unproblematic as practices were used to both include and exclude other girls, to reinforce social status and to marginalize others. Girls who were physically skilled and socially valued were able to exercise power and maintain their status through demonstrations of competence and strategies of inclusion and exclusion. Girls' activity choices and evaluations of physical education related to their own feelings of competence, the potential for positive or negative social interactions, and their ability to acquire and utilize desirable forms of social and physical capital. Implications for teaching include the necessity of incorporating inclusive practices that acknowledge the diverse range of girls' experiences, interests and needs, the need to reflect on the link between activities and social relationships, the possibility of incorporating space for critical reflection, and the influence of friendships and social networks.
BSC
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Bodies as bearers of value: the transmission of jock culture via the 'Twelve Commandments' |
|
This article explores a number of insights generated from a three-year ethnographic study of one university setting in England in which a 'jock culture' is seen to dominate a student campus. Drawing on core concepts from Pierre Bourdieu's sociology of culture, it illustrates the unique function of the body in sustaining jock culture through the hierarchical ordering of bodies in institutional space. First, the development of this culture over time and the key dispositions that come to embody it are outlined. Next, the authors identify and illustrate the enactment of what they call the 'Twelve Commandments'. These operate as a series of structured and structuring practices to condition the bodies of group members by appropriating an idealized and internalized jock habitus that is not gender neutral. Rather, it can be seen as a practical and symbolic manifestation of a dominant, heterosexual, masculine orientation to the world. The authors suggest that in spite of seemingly significant processes of accommodation over the years, the 'illusio' of this jock culture remains substantially intact and maintained through a combination of the following: (a) symbolic violence and (b) a systematic embodied complicity on the part of many of the actors who have something to gain by avoiding active subordination to, and exclusion from, the dominant group.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
'Why can't girls play football?' Gender dynamics and the playground |
|
This article focuses on the involvement of boys and girls in playground football. It is based on research conducted with 10- to 11-year-old pupils at two state primary schools in London. Boys and girls were found to draw on gender constructs that impacted variously on their involvement in playground football. The performance of masculinity through football translated into heavy investments for many boys who took any opportunity to prove both their knowledge and expertise in the sport. This investment rested on the derision and exclusion both of non-footballing boys and of girls. Associations between humility, restraint, niceness and femininity also had a negative impact on girls' involvement in the sport. Prohibitions around desire and determination proved especially damaging to girls' attempts at ownership and assertiveness within the game. This was compounded by boys' co-optation of football as 'inherently masculine'. Girls' resistance strategies to male domination of the football pitch tended to focus on disruption and rarely resulted in equal participation. This was due to opposition from powerful boys as well as entrenched gendered zones of play that granted boys automatic rights to football and girls only marginal tenancy.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
The meaning of social context: experiences of and educational outcomes of participation in two ... |
...different sports contexts
Based on a general belief in society about the good outcome of sport, this article critically examines the meaning—that is both the personal experience of participation and the potential educational outcome—which is derived from participation in two sport contexts under the umbrella of the Sports City Program (SCP) in Norway. With a theoretical framework based on the field theory of Bourdieu, and a qualitative methodological approach, the article indicates that there are differences within the SCP, with one pole of the SCP close to conventional sport, and the other pole more distinctly different from conventional sport. In short, there are different meanings derived from pursuing different contexts of the subfield of the SCP. Different sport contexts attract different adolescents, produce different experiences, and facilitate different educational opportunities. Out of the two SCP contexts investigated, the context most similar to conventional sport is based on family socialization and facilitates reproduction, while the context most distinct from conventional sport attracts other adolescents and clears the ground for self governance and an 'adolescent lifestyle'.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
The impact of media sport events on the active participation of young people and some implications.. |
|
...for PE pedagogy
This article addresses the impact of selected sports media events on the active participation of a group of young people aged 14/15. Its particular focus is on an intense period of media sport coverage during the European Soccer Championships (Euro '96), the Wimbledon Lawn Tennis Championships and the Atlanta Olympics and on how a group of British young people articulate ways that consumption of these products creates opportunities and challenges for their own sports participation.
The data reported here focus on one aspect drawn from a wider media sport and audience investigation designed within a hermeneutic and interpretative methodological framework. Through daily diaries and interviews this article draws particularly on young people's interpretations of sport and media as competing leisure activities and lifestyle choices; ways in which they perceive that watching sport provides them with new motivations and opportunities for physical activity; and the potential of sport media messages and images to 'inform and fashion performance'.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|